Inductee
A member of the Hall of Pretty Darn Good — voted in by the fans, celebrated here for being pretty darn good for a very long time, and loved for it.
A member of the Hall of Pretty Darn Good — voted in by the fans, celebrated here for being pretty darn good for a very long time, and loved for it.
Share this inductee’s page by copying the address in your browser — it ends in
Think of every name you’ve argued for at a bar, in a group chat, or over a family dinner — “How is they not in the Hall of Fame?” This Hall exists for exactly those arguments.
“Not the greatest of all time. Just… pretty darn good for a very long time, and loved for it.”
We celebrate the rock bands who sold millions without a Rock Hall call, the character actors who stole every scene, the .300 hitters, the 30-goal scorers, the quarterbacks who won you Sundays — the careers that made being a fan fun.
Scott keeps the roster, posts the matchups, counts every vote (nicknames and shorthand count too), and writes up the results. It’s a one-man commission with a very large, very opinionated electorate: you.
New here? Start by following on Facebook — that’s where the ballot lives. This site is the Hall’s front door and trophy case.
We argue for people here.
That’s the whole deal, and it’s non-negotiable. Every argument in this Hall is a case for somebody — why they mattered, why you loved them, why they deserve the plaque. If a name isn’t your favorite, make the case for yours instead.
Argue for somebody — it’s more fun anyway.
The Hall has one big idea: if the big halls already took care of you, you don’t need us. We’re here for everyone they missed.
That’s not a knock — it’s the whole point. Those folks went home to a bigger hall. We keep the door open for the rest.
♥ Tap the heart on any wing to like that category. Tap again to unlike — your likes are saved in this browser.
This is a sampler — the full roster runs past 300 names. Search for a favorite, filter by wing, and tap any name to open that inductee’s own page. If they’re not here yet, that’s what the Monday vote is for.
When we started this, we knew sooner or later some of our inductees would be inducted into a real Hall of Fame. We don’t remove them — stealing a line from Men in Black about Elvis: “He didn’t die; he went home.” That’s why this section is called They Went Home.
Inducted here first, then called up to their sport’s or music’s real Hall of Fame. We couldn’t be prouder — it proves the fans were right all along.
A few names waiting for their Monday. The full nominee list runs long — these are just near the top of the Commissioner’s desk:
The Hall lives on Facebook and Instagram. Follow along for the Monday matchup, the Friday results, and the daily noon spotlight — and bring a name with you. The best nominations always come from a fan who just can’t believe they’re not in yet.
— Scott “the Commissioner” Norman